Making Your Own Soap from Scratch: A Complete Beginner’s Guide
This website/blog post/store product listing may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you make a purchase through those links. There is no extra cost to you, the consumer.
Soapmaking is one of those timeless skills that connects us back to the past while offering a rewarding and practical craft for the present. For homesteaders, eco-conscious families, and DIY enthusiasts, making your own soap from scratch is a creative way to cut out unnecessary chemicals, save money, and craft beautiful, useful products for everyday life. Whether you want to reduce waste, control ingredients, or start a small side business, soapmaking has endless benefits.
In this guide, we’ll dive into the art and science of making soap from scratch, covering the different methods, essential tools, safety precautions, and step-by-step instructions so you can begin your journey with confidence.
---
Why Make Your Own Soap?
Homemade soap offers far more than just cleanliness—it’s about creating a healthier lifestyle and embracing sustainability. Here are a few reasons why soapmaking is worth the effort:
1. Ingredient Control – You know exactly what’s going into your soap, meaning you can avoid harsh detergents, parabens, and artificial fragrances.
2. Customization – Choose oils, scents, herbs, and colors that fit your preferences and skin type.
3. Sustainability – Making your own soap helps reduce packaging waste and promotes eco-friendly living.
4. Cost-Effectiveness – Over time, producing your own soap can be more affordable than buying natural, artisanal bars.
5. Homestead Skill – For those living a self-sufficient lifestyle, soapmaking is an invaluable skill.
6. Creative Outlet – It’s a craft where science meets art, allowing endless experimentation with scents, swirls, and shapes.
---
Understanding the Science of Soapmaking
At its core, soapmaking is a chemical reaction known as saponification. This occurs when fats or oils react with lye (sodium hydroxide), producing soap and glycerin.
Oils/Fats: These provide the moisturizing and cleansing properties of the soap. Examples include olive oil, coconut oil, palm oil, shea butter, and tallow.
Lye (Sodium Hydroxide): A strong alkali that’s necessary to turn oils into soap. Don’t worry—when used correctly, no lye remains in the finished bar.
Water: Helps dissolve the lye and blend it with oils.
Optional Additives: Essential oils, clays, dried herbs, exfoliants, or natural colorants.
Understanding this simple reaction helps you appreciate why measurements must be precise and why safety is key.
---
Methods of Soapmaking
There are a few primary methods used for making soap. Each comes with its own advantages depending on your skill level and goals.
1. Cold Process Soap
The most traditional and popular method. Oils and lye are mixed, traced (thickened), and poured into molds. The soap cures for 4–6 weeks before use.
Pros: Full creative control, customizable, natural glycerin preserved.
Cons: Long curing time, requires handling lye carefully.
2. Hot Process Soap
Similar to cold process, but the soap mixture is cooked in a slow cooker or oven to speed up saponification.
Pros: Soap is ready to use sooner (1–2 weeks curing), rustic appearance, forgiving for beginners.
Cons: Less smooth texture, fragrances can fade faster.
3. Melt and Pour Soap
This beginner-friendly method uses pre-made soap bases that are melted down, customized with scents and colors, and poured into molds.
Pros: No lye handling, quick results, fun for kids and beginners.
Cons: Less control over ingredients, less “from scratch.”
4. Rebatching Soap
Using grated or leftover soap that’s melted and re-formed.
Pros: Eco-friendly way to use scraps, saves failed batches.
Cons: Less appealing texture, limited design options.
For this post, we’ll focus primarily on cold process soap, since it’s the best way to truly make soap from scratch.
---
Safety First: Handling Lye
Before you dive into your first recipe, it’s crucial to respect the power of lye. While safe in finished soap, it can burn skin and damage surfaces during the process.
Soapmaking Safety Rules:
Always wear gloves, goggles, and long sleeves when handling lye.
Mix lye into water, never water into lye (to prevent dangerous eruptions).
Work in a well-ventilated area.
Use heat-resistant, non-aluminum equipment.
Store lye and raw soap safely away from children and pets.
---
Tools and Ingredients Needed
Here’s a basic list to get started with cold process soapmaking:
Tools
Digital kitchen scale (for precise measurements)
Heat-resistant mixing bowls
Stainless steel or plastic spoon/spatula
Stick blender
Thermometer
Soap mold (silicone or lined wooden mold)
Measuring cups
Safety gear (goggles, gloves, apron)
Ingredients
Base oils: Olive oil, coconut oil, shea butter, etc.
Lye (sodium hydroxide): Buy from a trusted supplier.
Distilled water (not tap water).
Essential oils for fragrance.
Additives: Natural colorants, dried herbs, exfoliants.
---
Step-by-Step: Cold Process Soapmaking
Here’s a simple beginner recipe and method:
Basic Soap Recipe (2-pound batch)
16 oz (1 lb) olive oil
8 oz coconut oil
8 oz palm oil (or shea butter if avoiding palm)
10.5 oz distilled water
4.4 oz lye
1–2 oz essential oil (optional)
Instructions
1. Prepare Your Work Area: Cover surfaces with newspaper, put on gloves and goggles, and measure all ingredients.
2. Mix the Lye Solution: Slowly pour lye into water (never the other way around). Stir until dissolved. The mixture will heat up and release fumes. Let it cool.
3. Melt Oils: In a separate pot, gently melt the oils until fully combined. Allow them to cool to around 100–110°F.
4. Combine Lye and Oils: When both are close in temperature (ideally within 10°F of each other), slowly pour the lye solution into the oils.
5. Blend to Trace: Use a stick blender to mix until the soap thickens to “trace” (like pudding consistency).
6. Add Extras: Stir in essential oils, herbs, or colorants.
7. Pour into Mold: Transfer the mixture into your mold, smooth the top, and cover with a towel.
8. Insulate and Set: Let the soap sit for 24–48 hours. Remove from mold and cut into bars.
9. Cure the Soap: Place bars on a rack in a cool, dry place for 4–6 weeks. This allows the soap to harden and fully saponify.
---
Creative Additions and Variations
Soapmaking offers endless customization. Once you’re comfortable with the basics, try these creative variations:
Herbal Soaps: Add dried lavender, chamomile, or calendula petals.
Exfoliating Soaps: Mix in ground oats, coffee grounds, or poppy seeds.
Colorful Swirls: Use natural colorants like spirulina (green), turmeric (yellow), or activated charcoal (black).
Moisturizing Bars: Add cocoa butter or avocado oil for extra skin-nourishing properties.
Scent Blends: Mix essential oils (like lavender + peppermint or citrus + rosemary).
---
Common Soapmaking Mistakes and Fixes
Even seasoned soapmakers run into issues. Here are a few common problems and solutions:
Soap Won’t Trace: Check your oil-to-lye ratio or blend longer.
Soap is Too Soft: Too much olive oil or not enough curing time.
Soap Cracks on Top: Soap overheated—insulate less or use a fan.
White Powdery Layer (Soda Ash): Caused by exposure to air—cover molds with plastic wrap.
Soap Separates: Oils and lye weren’t at similar temperatures when mixed.
---
Benefits of Homemade Soap
Homemade soap isn’t just about cleanliness—it’s about wellness, sustainability, and creativity. Some benefits include:
Gentle on Skin: No harsh chemicals or synthetic additives.
Rich in Glycerin: Naturally moisturizing, unlike many store-bought soaps.
Eco-Friendly: No plastic packaging, no chemical runoff.
Gift-Worthy: Handmade soap makes thoughtful, practical gifts.
Potential Income: Many homesteaders sell soap at markets, online, or through subscription boxes.
---
Final Thoughts: Embrace the Craft
Learning how to make soap from scratch is a rewarding journey that combines practical living with creativity. While it requires precision and patience, the results are well worth it: natural, eco-friendly soap that nourishes your skin and aligns with your values.
Whether you’re looking to live more sustainably, start a homestead business, or simply try a fun DIY project, soapmaking is a timeless skill to add to your repertoire. With a little practice, you’ll not only craft soap you can feel good about but also enjoy the satisfaction of creating something truly handmade.
So gather your oils, put on your safety gear, and take that first step into the fascinating world of soapmaking. Your skin—and the planet—will thank you.